I have seen four of the nominees for Best Picture at the 2022 Academy Awards — Don’t Look Up, Dune, The Power of the Dog, and West Side Story. I’m rooting for West Side Story.
Only people my age will have grown up hearing multiple versions of the songs — the original cast, the cast of the 1961 film, and the 1984 recording conducted by Leonard Bernstein and sung by opera stars including Kiri Te Kanawa. Given all those performances, it’s apparent how difficult it would be to surpass all those performances and set a new standard. In our time, who could have brought that off other than Steven Spielberg and Tony Kushner?
And it isn’t just the singing. It’s also the visuals, including the choreography and the vivid, constantly moving scenery (though there are a few quiet moments in scenes set at the Cloisters, “up above Harlem,” as Tony says). Even the drama — the parts that are not sung or danced — are compelling, though we know the story. Out on the streets, don’t miss out on the constant stream of 1950s cars! From the refrigerators to the ice cream sundae glasses, the retro visuals are beautiful (and accurate). Every member of the supporting cast is ridiculously talented, especially Mike Faist as Riff and Ariana DeBose as Anita. Rita Moreno, now age 90 and who portrayed Anita in the 1961 version, sings “Somewhere.” Some of the songs, including “Somewhere,” were recorded live, on camera. The Spanish accents and the untranslated Spanish make the story much more real. A trans character, Anybodys, played by the nonbinary Iris Menas, got West Side Story banned in such places as Saudi Arabia.
At 1:24 in the video, when “One Hand, One Heart” begins, watch Ansel Elgort’s throat, not only for the perfectly controlled and subtle vibrato but also for proof that the song was sung live on camera.
West Side Story can be streamed on Disney+ and HBO Max. The 2022 Academy Awards will be March 27.